1601 E. 5th St. #109

Austin, Texas 78702

United States


Module 002/2, Ground Floor, Tidel Park

Elcosez, Aerodome Post

Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu 641014 India


138G Grays Hill

Opp. BSNL GM Office, Sims Park

Coonoor, Tamil Nadu 643101 India


Block 7, Lot 5,

Camella Homes Bermuda,

Phase 2B, Brgy. Banlic,

City of Cabuyao, Laguna,


San Jose

Escazu Village

Calle 118B, San Rafael

San Jose, SJ 10203

Costa Rica

News & Insights

News & Insights

’Til Forbid

The business model for selling subscriptions online has been based, from the beginning, on the idea of an automatic renewal of a subscription as a core part of the subscription agreement. This is what was called the “til forbid” model in the business-to-business circulation management world of the 1980s, and that meant that the subscriber’s corporate credit card would be dinged on a periodic (usually annual) basis until the publisher was forbidden to do so. Prior to this, publishers would cancel and then re-start subscriptions, losing revenue in the process.

Ever since this model has been deployed, the trick for the circulation marketing team has always been in how to communicate that an automatic debit charge is coming (usually as quietly as possible) and how to handle the fallout from irate subscribers unprepared for the subscription renewal, which typically also involves a price increase.

There is some finesse to handling these interactions and successful publishers, along with the online services who followed them, were the ones who left the customers feeling a pang of subtle coercion but not enough annoyance to go out of their way to cancel their subscription.

These days, credit card issuers are actively addressing the issue of ‘zombie’ subscriptions by adding functionality to their online services that allow a consumer more transparency into their recurring transactions. I think there are lessons here for business-to-business publishers to use this tried-and-true model for their own renewals.

Some potential approaches to fine-tuning the automatic renewal process could include:

  • Performing an analysis of the subscriber’s usage patterns well in advance of the renewal date to highlight light users, who could then be offered training on getting the most out of their subscriptions. This also gives the customer retention team a heads-up.
  • Linking to a clear statement detailing how subscriber data will be used and specifying details on subscription renewal terms, potentially offering a “renewal at birth” option.
  • Adding a “deadman’s switch” to terminate a recurring subscription after a predetermined amount of time, perhaps five years.

This model focuses on customer ROI, gives invaluable customer satisfaction metrics, and offers the opportunity to stress the professionalism of the information provider. If carefully executed, this model should deliver results that are more than strong enough to justify the related expense of their implementation.

Keep on top of the information industry 
with our ‘Data Content Best Practices’ newsletter:

Keep on top of the information industry with our ‘Data Content Best Practices’ newsletter: